Custom cake makers in Columbus, OH

13 custom cake makers serving Columbus, Ohio. Compare ratings, specialties, and locations to find the right baker for your celebration.

Sort:

Sadie Baby Sweets

★ 5.0(193)

Bakery

Fate Cakes

★ 4.9(920)

Bakery

The Bearded Baker

★ 4.9(266)

Bakery

Bake Me Happy

★ 4.8(618)

Bakery

Herttys Bakeshop LLC

★ 4.8(80)

Cake shopCustom Cakes

Pattycake Bakery

★ 4.7(847)

Bakery

Three Bites Bakery

★ 4.7(202)

Bakery

Cakes and More

★ 4.7(149)

Bakery

Kennedy's Kakes

★ 4.7(88)

Cake shopCupcakesCustom Cakes

Happy Little Treats

★ 4.6(223)

Bakery

Kittie's Cakes

★ 4.5(189)

Bakery

The Pastry Factory

★ 4.5(45)

Pastries

Priscilla's Specialty Cakes

★ 3.9(8)

Bakery

Nearby cities in Ohio

Cincinnati (13)Cleveland (5)Athens (4)Dayton (4)Sandusky (4)Springfield (4)Beavercreek (2)Centerville (2)